BROCKTON, Mass. A zoning change that would open the way for 120 to 135 senior and affordable apartments at the Old Colony YMCA's downtown Brockton property will wait for another meeting, after a City Council committee postponed it Monday so a councilor could read the latest draft.
The Ordinance Committee voted by voice to put off both pieces, an amendment to the Brockton Smart Growth Overlay District and a zoning map change adding parcels 111-040, 111-041 and 111-042 to that district, until its next meeting. Committee Chair Shirley Asack, the Ward 7 councilor, said she plans to hold one in December.
Ward 4 Councilor Susan Nicastro, who made the motion, said she had not received the revised text. "I want to read it, I want to line by line it," she said. "It's complicated because of the changes that are made." She said the applicant was not opposed to the delay.
What is planned
Nicastro told viewers the overlay district was created downtown about 10 years ago and stops right beside the Y property on Main Street. She said the Y is deciding to move out of the building and is working with the proposed buyer, the Planning Office for Urban Affairs, which already has a senior housing project on Thatcher Street in her ward. "This is a zoning change. It's not a project approval," she said, "although it is kind of tantamount to a project because of the nature of how overlay districts work."
A representative of the Planning Office, the housing arm of the Archdiocese of Boston, told the committee the group estimates 120 to 135 units, about 72 of them for seniors. The representative said the group has built 3,200 units over 55 years and has 1,700 more in the works, and that the details of any set-asides, such as for veterans, are not settled while it waits on the zoning.
James Burke, a lawyer who represents the project, said the Y has been losing about $1 million a year on the downtown building and is not leaving the city. He said the new units would be apartments with their own kitchens and bathrooms, not single rooms, and that if the project moves forward "there will be no single room occupancy there." He noted the six-story building has housed single room occupancy since about 1917 as a use that predates current zoning. The old building, about 75 feet tall, would stay, he said, and any new buildings would be held to 55 feet.
He also said the proposal would lower the parking requirement to half a space per unit, only for senior housing and units that are 100% affordable, because many of those tenants do not have cars. He said the other overlay districts require 0.8 spaces per unit, and that he had talked about parking with Fire Chief Brian Nardelli.
A councilor's concerns
Ward 3 Councilor Philip Griffin asked who would manage the apartments and whether tenants would come from Boston. "I'm going to be upfront. This is my big concern with this project," he said, adding that the city has "done enough" to support low-income people and social service agencies and that he did not want Brockton to become "a mecca for that."
The Planning Office representative said the group follows the state's guidelines for marketing and leasing and that "most of the time it's residents in the area" who move in. Burke said the group oversees its own properties, though it may hire a management company. Burke said tenants could come from anywhere in the region, "from Taunton," or "from East Bridgewater," and that the draw would be new, affordable units. Nicastro said a 94-unit NeighborWorks project that opened in October received 1,200 applications, not all from Brockton, and that the Y property sits near the downtown train stop.
Accessory apartments and stormwater rules move ahead
The committee recommended that the full council adopt changes to the city's accessory dwelling unit ordinance, subject to a review by the Fire Department, after Nicastro asked whether fire officials had seen it. William Forte, the interim commissioner of buildings, said the changes bring the ordinance in line with the state's accessory dwelling unit regulations.
Under his draft, an apartment inside an existing home would still get an administrative review from the planning department but no site plan review; an existing garage, shed or pool house could be reused in the same footprint without zoning relief; a new detached unit would have 10-foot setbacks and could rise to 25 feet so it can have a normal pitched roof, while garages stay at 20 feet; and outside stairs visible from the street would be allowed on corner lots only. The fire chief would decide where a unit's power shutoff goes, and Public Works would decide its water and sewer connections. Forte said the 10-foot setback is a proposal and the council can make it larger.
The committee also recommended a rewritten stormwater management ordinance. Nicastro said she held three meetings to tighten the first draft, changing many places where the public works commissioner "may" act to "must," and adding a Stormwater Advisory Board of city department heads, a councilor and a resident to hear residents' concerns. Kyle Holden, the city's conservation agent, said the technical requirements now move into rules and regulations posted by Public Works, so they can change without a new ordinance. Griffin said developments in his ward had been held up by two different standards.
Both recommendations go to the full City Council. The council's next scheduled session is a special meeting at 6 p.m. Monday, Nov. 23, called for the yearly tax classification hearing, according to the city's public hearing notice. Asack, Nicastro, Griffin and at-large Councilor David Teixeira were the members present. Residents can reach councilors through the City Council page at brockton.gov.
Label: Reported by us.
Corrections
No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.








