The Plymouth Trial Court in Plymouth, a brick and glass courthouse with its name on a stone tower, seen across a wide lawn
Photo: Kevin Rutherford, CC BY-SA 4.0

Lindsay Clancy, the Duxbury mother charged with murder in the 2023 deaths of her three young children, is due back in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday, Nov. 16, a week after the judge in her case ruled that a second trial would not violate her protection against double jeopardy.

Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy J. Cruz has said he intends to decide by Monday whether to retry Clancy, CNN reported Sunday, and Boston.com described Monday's session as a conference hearing where prosecutors are expected to decide whether to pursue a retrial. Cruz has not said whether his office would try Clancy again on first-degree murder charges or on reduced charges, Boston.com and CNN reported; the jurors at her first trial were also allowed to consider second-degree murder and manslaughter, according to CNN. Judge William Sullivan has floated March 2027 for a retrial, according to CNN, Boston.com and Courthouse News Service, while Clancy's attorney, Kevin Reddington, has said he is eyeing April, Boston.com reported.

The ruling

In a 17-page decision on Monday, Nov. 9, Sullivan denied Clancy's motion to dismiss the case, Courthouse News Service reported. "A hung jury is a traditional example of manifest necessity that permits retrial without offending double jeopardy," Sullivan wrote, according to Courthouse News.

Clancy's lawyers had argued that the judge should have questioned the lone juror who held out against the rest of the panel before the judge declared a mistrial in September, according to Boston.com and WBUR. Sullivan wrote that the record "did not reasonably suggest Juror Doe's inability to deliberate or refusal to follow the law," Courthouse News reported, and he found that information that came out about the juror after the trial "cannot serve to undermine" the mistrial decision, CNN reported.

In separate orders the same day, Sullivan denied the defense request for the holdout juror's records, including his jury questionnaire and cellphone records, and turned down the prosecution's request for a gag order on Clancy's lawyers, CNN and Boston.com reported. He wrote that prosecutors may renew the gag order request if circumstances change, according to Courthouse News and CNN.

Martin G. Weinberg, an appellate lawyer on Clancy's defense team, wrote to Boston.com that he expects an appeal to the Supreme Judicial Court in the "very near future." The district attorney's office declined to comment on the rulings, CNN and Courthouse News reported.

How the case got here

Clancy, 36, faces three counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of her children, 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan, at the family's Duxbury home in January 2023, according to CNN and Boston.com. At trial, her lawyers did not deny that she killed the children but argued she should not be held criminally responsible because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis, CNN and Boston.com reported.

Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4 after jurors deliberated for seven days without reaching a unanimous verdict, according to Boston.com. Several jurors said in later interviews that a single holdout kept the panel from finding Clancy not guilty by lack of criminal responsibility, CNN reported.

At a Nov. 2 hearing, Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague told the court, "This would be a retrial," and added, "As to what that looks like, it will depend. We're not at that point yet," according to Courthouse News. Sullivan faces mandatory retirement in June 2027, CNN and WBUR reported, and Reddington told him at the Nov. 2 hearing, "I want a trial and I want it with you and I want it this spring," according to WBUR.

Clancy has been held at Tewksbury Hospital since 2023, WBUR and Courthouse News reported. Clancy is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

South Shore 360 will update this story after Monday's hearing, where prosecutors are expected to say how they will proceed.

Label: Reported by us.