The Brockton City Council has moved $18.2 million out of a reserve built with savings from the city's 2021 pension bond, using it to cover budget holes that stood in the way of setting the city's fiscal 2027 tax rate.

The council approved the transfer of $18,184,462.35 from the Pension Stabilization Fund on an 11-0 roll call on Nov. 9, a week after its Finance Committee recommended it. Interim Chief Financial Officer John Condon told the committee on Nov. 2 that about $4 million will be left in the fund.

"This is an appropriation which we're looking to use to get rid of everything which is standing in the way of us from setting our tax rate," Condon told the Finance Committee. He said the state Department of Revenue had told the city it must clear its past deficits before it would approve a tax rate, and that he had no source of funding other than the reserve.

Retirees' pensions are not affected

Condon said the fund is separate from the retirement system. It was set up with budget savings after the city sold pension obligation bonds in 2021, to soften the city's pension bill in a down market. "It has nothing to do with the bond payments, nor does it have anything to do with the pension payments for the city employees," he said. He told councilors the retirement system is about 90% funded.

What the $18.2 million pays for

  • $4,302,507 to cover fiscal 2027 revenue the city will not collect. Condon said the budget counted on $4 million from selling the police building, a figure the state questioned, and a new growth estimate the chairman of the Board of Assessors considered too high. Ward 5 Councilor Jeffrey Thompson said the city's request for proposals for the building drew no takers.
  • $4,787,311.66 for a deficit in school spending that falls outside the state's net school spending requirement. Condon said it is "almost entirely transportation," from last year's school transportation deficit.
  • $3,791,386.95 for a deficit in the city's CARES fund.
  • $2 million for desalination charges under the city's contract with Aquaria, which were left out of the budget passed in June. Public Works Commissioner Patrick Hill said he raised the gap during budget hearings.
  • $2.2 million for workers' compensation and $500,000 for Law Department goods and supplies. Those two lines match the $2.7 million City Solicitor James O'Brien requested in a letter placed on file Oct. 26: $2.2 million for outstanding medical claims of two Brockton firefighters injured on duty, $350,000 to settle a federal lawsuit brought by the estate of Afonso Brandao against the city, its police chief and officers, and enough to bring the department's judgment account back to $150,000.
  • $453,256.74 for a snow and ice deficit and $150,000 for the auditor's mail account.

The pieces add up to the full $18,184,462.35.

'It must stop'

The CFO's written certification of the request, in the council's Oct. 26 minutes, said "the City's reserves are now deeply depleted" and that without the transfer "the City will be forced to pursue even more drastic measures to achieve tax rate certification."

Before the Nov. 9 vote, Ward 4 Councilor Susan Nicastro said $6.3 million of the bills corrects the fiscal 2027 budget the council passed in June, and $8.6 million covers school overspending of CARES Act grant money and transportation funds. "I'm voting to use this $18 million tonight to pay these bills, but it must stop. We're literally running out of money to do this," she said. She said she would file a resolve on how the council can hold officials accountable for overspending, pointing to a section of the city's 1990 finance law, Chapter 324 of the Acts of 1990, that makes officials who knowingly spend more than their department's appropriation personally responsible.

At the Finance Committee, Thompson said the city auditor had shown that about $12 million in stabilization money already went to balance fiscal 2027, so this transfer brings the total to about $30 million. At-large Councilor Winthrop Farwell Jr. asked Condon and Mayor Moises Rodrigues to have every department head certify there are no other unpaid bills. Condon said he would send that request.

Fiscal 2028 outlook

Condon said a multimillion-dollar shortfall looms for fiscal 2028, which starts July 1, 2027. "It's a big number and it's going to require some pain to get into balance," he said. He said he hopes to limit cuts to services and layoffs, "but I don't think it's possible to say we're not going to have some of that kind of pain."

He said he would bring the mayor and council a forecast and recommendations this calendar year, so the city can go to the Legislature early next year. Options he named include borrowing to spread out the cost, which Thompson noted would need state approval, and relief from the rule that the city fully replenish its Chapter 324 reserve. He said the city may also need more money "whether they're from the state or whether they're internal to the city residents and asking them to pay more," noting that the city taxes residents only about $12 per $1,000 of value, which he said leaves room if voters were willing to approve more.

Condon also said the desalination charge should be paid from water revenue rather than the general fund, but that the water fund does not bring in enough today and would need a rate increase to cover it.

Rodrigues told the committee "we continue to spend beyond our means in this city," pointing out that almost 90% of the budget is personnel. "Everything is on the table," he said.

Also approved

On Nov. 9 the council also accepted $425,000 in federal American Rescue Plan Act money passed through Plymouth County for the City Hall heating and ventilation project, which must be spent by Dec. 31. On Oct. 26 it authorized borrowing $2.3 million for fire trucks on a 9-0 vote.

What happens next

The Finance Committee meets tonight, Monday, Nov. 16, at 7 p.m. in the City Council Chambers at City Hall, 45 School St. The council's fiscal 2027 tax classification hearing, where it decides how the tax levy is split between homes and businesses, is Monday, Nov. 23, at 6 p.m. in the same room. At that hearing the council sets the residential factor and may also choose whether to adopt a residential exemption or a small commercial exemption, neither of which Brockton has adopted before, according to the Board of Assessors' hearing packet. Both meetings air on Brockton Community Access, which streams them on its YouTube channel.

Label: Reported by us.