The John Joseph Moakley U.S. Courthouse, a red brick building with a curved glass front, on the Boston waterfront with sailboats in the harbor in front of it
Photo: 4300streetcar, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

A Pembroke man who once led the U.S. Postal Inspection Service's mail fraud team in Boston, which investigated scams aimed at older people, was sentenced Wednesday to 40 months in prison for stealing cash that scam victims had mailed, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Massachusetts said.

U.S. District Judge Allison D. Burroughs sentenced Scott Kelley, 52, a former U.S. postal inspector, and ordered three years of supervised release to follow his prison term, the office said in a release Thursday. Burroughs also ordered him to pay a $20,000 fine, $106,986 in restitution and a special assessment of $4,400, according to the office. Kelley is to report to prison Jan. 7, 2027, at a facility the federal Bureau of Prisons will designate, the court docket shows.

Victim impact statements were given at Wednesday's hearing in federal court in Boston, and Kelley spoke on his own behalf before the sentence was imposed, according to the docket. Burroughs also agreed to reconsider a forfeiture money judgment the court entered against him Nov. 10 and gave him seven days to file a brief on it. The case is United States v. Kelley, No. 1:25-cr-10355-ADB. South Shore 360 asked Kelley's lawyer, Daniel J. Gaudet, for comment on Nov. 19 and had no answer by publication.

Kelley pleaded guilty July 29 to five counts of wire fraud, five counts of mail fraud, five counts of mail theft by a postal officer, 23 counts of money laundering, one count of structuring to evade reporting requirements and five counts of filing false tax returns, according to the office and the docket. Those are 44 of the 45 counts in the indictment a federal grand jury in Boston returned against him in August 2025, when he pleaded not guilty to all of them. The remaining count, theft of government money, was not part of his plea, and the docket lists no sentence on it. His plea came less than four weeks before a jury trial that had been set for Aug. 24.

What prosecutors said he did

Kelley worked at the Boston Division headquarters of the U.S. Postal Inspection Service, the law enforcement arm of the Postal Service, and was authorized to carry a firearm, make arrests and execute search warrants, the office said. In 2015 he became the leader of the service's Mail Fraud team, supervising inspectors who investigated lottery and other scams that targeted senior citizens, according to prosecutors. He moved to lead the service's Mail Theft Unit in June 2022 and held that post until August 2023, the office said when he was charged.

The Postal Inspection Service worked with Jamaican law enforcement on a program called Jamaican Operations Linked to Telemarketing, or JOLT, to disrupt scams in which callers posing as lottery representatives persuaded older people to mail cash to cover "fees" or "taxes" on prizes that did not exist, the office said. Inspectors in the program could intercept packages believed to come from scam victims, but they could open one only with the sender's consent and otherwise had to mail it back, the office said when Kelley was charged.

Beginning no later than 2016, Kelley used his authority to have inspectors and staff he supervised, and postal employees around the country, reroute flagged packages to him under the guise of investigative work, prosecutors said. Between January 2019 and Aug. 11, 2023, he asked for at least 1,950 of those parcels, received hundreds, opened the ones that looked or felt like they held cash and took the cash inside, according to the office.

The office listed 13 of his victims, from 11 states, three of them in Massachusetts. They include a retired Army veteran in Kansas, then 76, who mailed $19,100; a retired nurse with Parkinson's disease living in Massachusetts, then 78, who mailed $5,400; and a Massachusetts man with dementia, then 76 and since deceased, who mailed $24,500.

The office said it does not know how much Kelley stole in all, but that he had about $340,000 in cash in the last four and a half years of the thefts alone. He deposited about $131,000 without ever making a deposit large enough to require a bank to report it to federal regulators, and he spent about $160,000 in cash on roughly 165 postal money orders, never buying $3,000 or more in a single day, prosecutors said. He also made almost $50,000 in cash purchases, including $20,500 for a patio around his backyard pool, work on his pool and outdoor bar, expenses on Caribbean cruises and $15,400 paid to two prostitutes he met during workdays, according to the office.

"As a sworn law enforcement officer, Scott Kelley was entrusted with protecting our community from predators. Instead, he became one himself," U.S. Attorney Leah B. Foley said in the release. "A badge is a symbol of public trust, not a license to steal."

Thomas Demeo, special agent in charge of IRS Criminal Investigation's Boston Field Office, said Kelley "intentionally used the USPS' own controls, designed to protect the victims of fraud, for his own gains by stealing packages of cash that were intended to be returned to the victims of scams."

Agents of the Postal Service's Office of Inspector General and IRS Criminal Investigation handled the case with cooperation from the Postal Inspection Service, and Assistant U.S. Attorneys Christine Wichers and Eric L. Hawkins prosecuted it, the office said.

Where to report a scam

The U.S. Attorney's Office asks anyone who believes they may be a victim in this case, or of another elder fraud scam, to email USAMA.VictimAssistance@usdoj.gov. Suspected mail fraud can also be reported to the U.S. Postal Inspection Service online or by calling (877) 876-2455, the office said.

Label: Reported by us.